Back to Tools

HELOC vs Mortgage Calculator

Compare converting your HELOC to a fixed mortgage vs making extra principal payments. Uses the same methodology as the HELOC vs Fixed Mortgage analysis .

Your scenario

This amount will be used in the comparison table below. Leave at 0 to compare against HELOC-only strategy.

Key insights

Read full analysis
Best strategy

$300,000 converted

Convert 100% to fixed mortgage

$14,880
Interest saved
Monthly payment

$1,567

vs $1,163 HELOC interest-only

+$404
Difference
Principal paid

$39,149

Over 5 years

13% of balance
Reduction

Fixed conversion vs HELOC + extra payments

Converting $300,000 saves you $14,880 in interest compared to keeping everything in HELOC, even with extra payments.

Read full analysis →

Strategy 1: Conversion to fixed

Monthly payments at different conversion amounts.

Amount convertedHELOC remainingMortgage P&IHELOC interestTotal monthly
$0$300,000$0$1,163$1,163
$50,000$250,000$261$969$1,230
$100,000$200,000$522$775$1,297
$150,000$150,000$783$581$1,365
$200,000$100,000$1,045$388$1,432
$250,000$50,000$1,306$194$1,500
$300,000$0$1,567$0$1,567

5-year outcomes: Conversion

Principal paid, interest paid, and remaining debt over 5 years.

Amount convertedPrincipal paidTotal interestInterest saved vs HELOCRemaining debt
$0$0$69,750$0$300,000
$50,000$6,525$67,270$2,480$293,475
$100,000$13,050$64,790$4,960$286,950
$150,000$19,575$62,310$7,440$280,425
$200,000$26,100$59,830$9,920$273,900
$250,000$32,624$57,350$12,400$267,376
$300,000$39,149$54,870$14,880$260,851

Strategy 2: HELOC + extra payments

Keep balance in HELOC and add a fixed extra principal payment each month.

Extra paymentStarting interestAvg monthly paymentPrincipal paid (5yr)Balance after 5 years
$0$1,163$1,163$0$300,000
$500$1,163$1,605$30,000$270,000
$600$1,163$1,694$36,000$264,000
$700$1,163$1,782$42,000$258,000

Strategy comparison

Compare all three strategies side-by-side with key metrics.

Metric
Conversion
$300,000
HELOC Only
(No conversion)
HELOC + Extra
$500/month
Monthly payment$1,567$1,163$1,605
Total interest paid$54,870$69,750$66,321
Principal paid$39,149$0$30,000
Remaining debt$260,851$300,000$270,000
Interest vs HELOC only−$14,880
Saved
—−$3,429
Saved
Total amount paid$94,020$69,750$96,321

Want more details?

Read the complete analysis with detailed methodology, formulas, risk scenarios, and real-world recommendations.

Read full analysis

How this HELOC vs mortgage calculator works

This calculator compares two ways to handle a home equity line of credit (HELOC) balance: convert some or all of it to a fixed-rate mortgage, or keep the balance on the HELOC and optionally add extra principal each month. The math matches the approach in the HELOC vs fixed mortgage article: a standard amortizing payment on the converted amount, and interest-only carrying cost on the HELOC amount that remains.

You enter HELOC balance, HELOC rate, fixed mortgage rate, amortization in years, and an analysis period in years. The conversion tables show monthly mortgage principal-and-interest, remaining HELOC interest, and total monthly cost at several conversion amounts. The outcomes table shows principal paid, total interest, interest versus leaving everything on the HELOC, and remaining debt over the analysis period. A second strategy keeps the full balance on the HELOC and applies a monthly extra principal amount you choose. The comparison table lines up conversion, HELOC-only, and HELOC plus extra payments.

Enter your own balance and rates. Set how many years you want to inspect. Use “Conversion amount to compare” to test a partial conversion, or the buttons to jump to the tool’s suggested conversion or the full balance. Adjust the extra payment to see how a paydown strategy changes average monthly cost and remaining balance. If the HELOC rate you entered is lower than the fixed rate, the page flags that converting would cost more in interest under those inputs.

The HELOC portion is treated as interest-only unless you add extra principal. The fixed portion uses a standard amortized payment over the amortization you enter. Rates are held constant for the analysis period. There are no fees, penalties, or insurance in the math. Extra payments go to principal.

Variable HELOC rates change in the real world; this tool does not simulate future rate paths. It does not apply a lender’s conversion rules, qualification tests, or tax treatment. Results are estimates for the numbers you type. This is not financial advice. Read the full analysis and speak with your lender or advisor before you convert or prepay.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between the two strategies?+

Strategy 1 converts part or all of the HELOC to a fixed amortized mortgage. Strategy 2 keeps the balance on the HELOC and, if you choose, adds a fixed extra principal payment each month. The comparison table also shows HELOC-only with no extra.

How does the calculator treat the remaining HELOC?+

The remaining HELOC is treated as interest-only at the HELOC rate you enter, unless you model extra principal in strategy 2. The converted amount uses a standard principal-and-interest payment over the amortization you set.

What if my HELOC rate is already lower than the fixed rate?+

The tool shows a warning and treats “keep the balance on the HELOC” as the lower-interest path under those inputs. Conversion can still change monthly cash flow and principal paid; read both tables before you decide.

Can I model a partial conversion?+

Yes. Set “Conversion amount to compare” to any amount up to the balance, or use the buttons for the tool’s suggested conversion or the full balance. Tables also step through several conversion amounts.

Does the tool include fees or future rate changes?+

No. Rates stay constant for the analysis period. Fees, penalties, insurance, and tax treatment are not included. A real HELOC rate can move; this page does not path that risk.

Is this financial advice?+

No. It is an educational comparison from the numbers you enter. Confirm conversion rules and payments with your lender and a qualified advisor. The matching article walks through the same methodology in more detail.

Educational estimates only. This is not financial, tax, or legal advice.